1706 Seminary Street has been quietly dazzling Key West for weeks—open houses galore, rave feedback, and rental opportunity. Priced at $2,299,000, this 3‑bed, 3‑bath, nearly 1,940 sq ft residence sits on a spacious 7,480 sq ft lot. Completely reimagined behind a fresh privacy fence, it’s ready for someone to call home—either full time, part time, or as a rental.
Mark your calendar: Open House Saturday, June 21st from 11AM–1PM. Come see what all the buzz is about!
View full listing on the MLS | Check it out on Zillow
Indoor‑Outdoor Flow That Feels Like Paradise
Step inside and feel the breeze. Glass‑wrapped family room floods the space with light and warmth—especially with that wood‑burning fireplace flickering as a centerpiece. Slide the doors open and you’re poolside in seconds. That effortless meld of inside and out? Pure island magic.
Outdoor Entertaining Spaces
Outside, meandering pathways guide you through lush new landscaping (hello, 2025 updates) to a resort‑style L‑shaped lap pool. Multiple covered lounge zones, Bahama‑style dining area, outdoor shower, and shed storage make entertaining a breeze—whether it's cocktail hour, family BBQ, or poolside chill.
Flexible Floor Plan + Rental Appeal
This home’s layout is smart. A primary bedroom with an en-suite plus a third bedroom with its own private entrance create the perfect lock‑out suite—ideal for guests or long‑term rentals. Combine that with separate HVAC zones, and you’ve got a flexible setup for family, guests, or income-producing stays.
2024–25 Upgrades: Turn‑Key Ready
Everything’s been done:
-
2024 full renovation: reconfigured to 3 beds/3 baths, new kitchen with quartz waterfall counters, custom cabinetry, KitchenAid appliances, new flooring throughout
-
2024 replaced all cast‑iron plumbing
-
2020 new roof and central AC; 2025 new privacy fence and landscaping
-
Tankless water heater, working fireplace
All systems are fresh, so your only worry? Whether to host or to move in.
There’s something special about 1511 South Street. Tucked away in the heart of Midtown, this fully renovated property has been catching serious attention, received multiple offers and has recently gone under contract. Priced at $2,399,999, it’s a private tropical retreat that balances form, function, and fun.
Mark your calendar: Open House Saturday, June 14th from 11AM–1PM. Come see what all the buzz is about and check it out before it goes off the market! Click here to see the listing in full
Effortless Indoor-Outdoor Vibe
One of the most captivating elements of this property is its seamless flow between interior comfort and exterior charm. With impact-rated doors from nearly every room, the indoors are always just steps from sun and sky.
The main house boasts vaulted ceilings, an airy open layout, and a commercial-style kitchen that connects directly to the covered carport. Whether you're sipping morning coffee or hosting cocktail hour, this space transitions effortlessly to suit your vibe.
Entertaining Paradise
When it comes to hosting, 1511 South Street doesn’t hold back. French doors open to a Caribbean-inspired 18′ x 14′ loggia and a fully equipped outdoor kitchen by Paradise Grills. The heated pool, resurfaced in 2024 and surrounded by low-maintenance composite decking and stonework, becomes the centerpiece of the outdoor experience.
Throw in an outdoor shower, multiple lounging zones, and canvas-shaded spaces, and you’ve got the ultimate entertainment retreat. Whether it's intimate dinners or full-blown celebrations, this home sets the scene beautifully.
Flexible Living for Family & Guests
With 4 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms across two separate dwellings, this property was designed for flexibility.
The main house features 2 beds and 2 baths, each with direct pool access and electronic blinds for those lazy island mornings. The two-story guest cottage is a showstopper in its own right — fully renovated in 2024, with a bedroom and bath on each floor, walk-in closets, and a dedicated generator for added peace of mind.
Whether you need a private home office, guest suite, or an ideal setup for hosting visiting family and friends, this layout has you covered.
A Long List of Improvements (2024–2025)
This isn’t just a refreshed home — it’s practically brand-new. Here’s a snapshot of the recent upgrades:
✅ 2024
-
Full renovation of guest cottage
-
Pool resurfacing
-
Outdoor kitchen installation
-
New composite decking and pavers
-
Impact windows and doors throughout
-
New outdoor shower
✅ 2025
-
Entire property professionally repainted
-
Refinished IPE decking
These high-ticket updates make this a true move-in-ready property. No deferred maintenance here — just start living.
Open House: Saturday, June 21st
📍 1706 Seminary Street, Key West
📅 Saturday, June 21, 2025
⏰ 11:00 AM – 1:00 PM
🔔 Here’s the Ask
This home has received noise—now it needs action. If you’ve toured and loved it, now’s the time to step up. In a market where few properties tick every box, 1706 Seminary Street does. Don’t let this opportunity slip. Stop by — or contact me to schedule a private showing.
You Should Be Here,
🐓KWT🐓
BONUS: Real Estate Notes for the Savvy Buyer
💰 Financing Tip:
Since this property includes two separate dwellings and is zoned for single-family use, buyers have great flexibility. You can live in one side and rent out the other, or simply rent the whole place when you're not using it — a smart way to offset costs and let your Key West home help pay for itself!
📊 Market Comparison:
Looking for other Midtown homes that are fully renovated in this price range? There aren’t many — and this one truly stands out. Serious buyers are already circling, so if it’s on your radar, let’s talk before it’s off the market.
Got questions about this listing or others like it? Call or text me anytime.
—
Ted Stewart
📱 (305) 399‑0330
🌐 www.keywestted.com
🏡 Truman & Co. Real Estate
IG and Facebook: @keywestted
