If you’ve been searching for a true Key West unicorn—a commercial space with visibility, history, flexibility, and serious investment upside—consider this your sign. Located on one of the island’s most trafficked corridors, 1010 Truman Avenue is more than just a building—it’s a cornerstone of Old Town culture. Whether you're a seasoned investor or a visionary ready to plant your flag in paradise, this iconic property is primed for its next chapter.
View the complete listing here: Click Here
A Building with Muscle and Memory 💪
For decades, 1010 Truman Ave has been home to Old Town Fitness, lovingly referred to as Southernmost Muscle. This isn't your average strip-mall gym—it's a Key West institution with local grit and global flavor. Inside, you'll find an unforgettable interior adorned with Irish pride, Conor McGregor posters, flags from around the world, and a front door fashioned from a dumbbell. It's a space that doesn’t just welcome you—it challenges you.
More than just brawn, the property has benefited from thoughtful upgrades over time: a new roof, impact windows, plumbing and electrical updates, stucco repairs, and a wired security system. It’s a structure that balances nostalgic charm with modern infrastructure—ready for whatever comes next.
Investment Potential with No Ceilings
With over 5,000 square feet on an 8,102 square foot lot, this property offers size, flexibility, and even the potential to go vertical—with the possibility to build a second story (buyer to verify). Off-street parking for four or more vehicles gives you a rare edge in Old Town. Whether you envision a boutique gym, wellness hub, Golf Club rental, co-working space, or something completely out of the box, 1010 Truman offers a solid foundation for any business venture. Its open layout and clean lines make reimagining the space refreshingly doable.
A+ Location in Old Town
Location in real estate isn’t everything—it’s the only thing. And 1010 Truman Avenue sits front and center on one of the most high-traffic streets in Key West. Think constant visibility, walkable surroundings, and easy access to Duval, White Street, and the Southernmost Point. Locals know this corner. Tourists can’t help but pass it. When you factor in the visibility, existing charm, and versatility of the space, you’re not just buying real estate—you’re securing a piece of Key West’s commercial soul.
Whether you're continuing its legacy or crafting something entirely new, this is your chance to own a standout property in one of the most unique markets in the country.
📍1010 Truman Avenue, Key West | 5,016 SF Interior | 8,102 SF Lot
View the complete listing, which includes pricing, here: Click Here
You Should Be Here,
🐓 Key West Ted 🐓
Want to see it in person? Contact me at:
—
Ted Stewart
📱 (305) 399‑0330
🌐 www.keywestted.com
🏡 Truman & Co. Real Estate
IG and Facebook: @keywestted
